Historic masterpiece in Mission Hills. Faithfully restored 1917 Prairie landmark built by master builder Nathan Rigdon. Rich in San Diego heritage, this Mills Act 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom residence seamlessly blends timeless Craftsman artistry with high-end modern upgrades. This significant home is on one of the best streets in Mission Hills. The home welcomes you with a classic full-width porch set above the street. Inside, discover pristine quarter-sawn oak flooring, octagonal oak columns, coved ceilings in oak, oak beams and mullion pocket doors. There are Craftsman fixtures throughout, period fireplace tile, and an oak-paneled dining room complete with a stunning built-in china cabinet and period fixture. The Craftsman kitchen features green granite countertops and serves as a natural gathering spot for guests and family. The spacious living room leads into an inviting family room and out to a charming sunroom that opens to a Tuscan Villa-inspired walled courtyard. This outdoor space is remarkable and visually arresting. It represents the best of indoor-outdoor living, featuring a vine-covered al fresco dining area, a spacious sunny garden built for entertaining, drought-resistant landscaping, teak gates, mature olive trees, serene fountains, and a gas firepit. Solar panels, three tankless water heaters, and significant Mills Act property tax savings make this home as practical as it is beautiful. A custom finished garage built in 2007 offers alley access, epoxy floors, full cabinetry, wine and full-sized refrigerators, sink, ceiling fans, and a 220V EV charger.
Listing Provided Courtesy of Jim Scott at Scott & Quinn Real Estate
Property Details
Price:
$3,495,000
MLS #:
260022158
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Baths:
3
Type:
Single Family
Subdivision:
MISSION HILLS
Neighborhood:
metrouptown
Listed Date:
Sep 10, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
2,500
Total Sq Ft:
2,500
Lot Size:
6,825 sqft / 0.16 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1917
See this Listing
Schools
Interior
Appliances
Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Garage Door Opener, Refrigerator, Solar Panels, Built In Range, Ice Maker, Range/Stove Hood, Gas Range
Bathrooms
3 Full Bathrooms
Cooling
N/K
Fireplaces Total
1
Heating
Zoned Areas, Forced Air Unit
Interior Features
Crown Moldings
Laundry Features
Electric, Gas
Levels
2 Story
Exterior
Architectural Style
Craftsman
Construction Materials
Stucco
Fencing
Full, Gate, Privacy, Blockwall
Garage Spaces
2
Parking Features
Detached
Parking Spots
2
Parking Total
2
Patio And Porch Features
Stone/Tile, Patio
Roof
Composition, Shingle
Security Features
Eqpt Owned
View
City
Financial
Map
Community
- Address4250 Arguello Street San Diego CA
- SubdivisionMISSION HILLS
- CitySan Diego
- CountySan Diego
- Zip Code92103
Subdivisions in San Diego
- 18th Unit 18U
- Acacia Park ACAP
- Allied Gardens
- Alta 33401
- Alta ALTA
- Alta Vista AV
- Arborlake AL
- BAY PARK
- Bayside BS
- Bayview Heights 570
- Belvedere BEL
- Brentwood BRTW
- Cambria CAMB
- CAMPO
- Carmel CRM
- CARMEL MOUNTAIN RANCH
- CARMEL VALLEY
- CHULA VISTA
- CITY HEIGHTS
- Civita CIVI
- CLAIREMONT
- Clifton Heights CLFH
- Collage COLG
- College Estates1260
- COLLEGE GROVE
- College Park COLG
- College Park CP
- College View Estates 32235
- Columbia COLU
- Columbia Square CS
- Cortez CZ
- Creekside CR
- Crestmont CSM
- CROWN POINT
- Crown Point CP
- DEL CERRO
- Del Cerro 337
- Del Cerro DELC
- DEL MAR
- Del Mar 31415
- DOWNTOWN
- Downtown 605
- Downtown Area DOWN
- Downtown DT
- EAST DEL MAR
- EAST ESCONDIDO
- EAST SAN DIEGO
- East Village 400
- EL CAJON
- Embarcadero750
- Emerald Hills EMER
- ENCANTO
- Encanto 31424
- Encanto ENCAN
- Escala ESCL
- Fashion Heights FSHH
- Golden View GLDV
- Hampton Place HAMP
- Hidden Canyon 760
- High Country 780
- Highland Estates 379
- HILLCREST
- Hillcrest Estates HILE
- Hillcrest HC
- Hillcrest HLCR
- Hillcrest Park HLCT
- Horizon HORZ
- Horizons HORZ
- IMPERIAL BEACH
- KEARNY MESA
- KENSINGTON
- Kensington KENS
- Kensington Park 787
- Knightsbridge KBRG
- LA JOLLA
- La Jolla Townehomes LJOL
- LA MESA
- La Morada 31523
- La Paz South LP
- LEMON GROVE
- Lexington LEX
- Lexington LEXT
- LINDA VISTA
- LOGAN HEIGHTS
- Maplewood MAPW
- Marbella MB
- Mid Town 604
- MIDDLETOWN
- MIRA MESA
- Mirasol MIR
- MISSION BEACH
- Mission Greens R1 MG
- Mission Greens R2 MG
- MISSION HILLS
- Mission Hills/Fairway1862
- Mission Hills/Haciendas 32151
- Mission Hills/Westgate 32155
- MISSION VALLEY
- MISSION VILLAGE
- Mission Village MA
- Mobile Estates ME
- Montelena MTL
- Monteverde MVRD
- Mountain View 200
- NATIONAL CITY
- None2161
- NORMAL HEIGHTS
- NORTH PARK
- Not Applicable1
- Oak Park 867
- Oak Park OKPK
- OCEAN BEACH
- Ocean Hills OH
- Ocean View Homes OCVI
- Ocean View Terrace OVTR
- OLD TOWN
- PACIFIC BEACH
- Pacific Heights PACH
- Palacio Del Mar PD
- PARADISE HILLS
- Park Terrace Village PKTV
- Park Villas II PKV2
- Park Villas PKVL
- Park West 1126
- Parkview Condos 187
- Placerita CanyonMaster’s Colleg
- Plaza del Sol 479
- POINT LOMA
- RANCHO BERNARDO
- Rancho Pacifica 1 261701
- RANCHO PENASQUITOS
- RANCHO SANTA FE
- Regency Villas RGVL
- Ridge – Pacific Ridge RIDG
- SABRE SPR
- SAN CARLOS
- San Carlos SANC
- SAN DIEGO
- SAN YSIDRO
- SANTALUZ
- Savannah SAVA
- SCRIPPS RANCH
- Seaview SEA
- SERRA MESA
- Skyline Homes SKYL
- Skyline SKYL
- Smoke Tree SMTR
- Sorrento SO
- South Park 304
- SOUTH SD
- SPRING VALLEY
- Starlight Mesa Dist 14 STME
- Stonebridge 3700
- Stonecrest 892
- Summerwood Homes SMWD
- Sunburst 30922
- Sunrise SU
- Sunset Village SN
- TALMADGE
- Talmadge TALM
- The Bluffs2010
- The Greens GRNS
- The Trails 171
- TIERRASANTA
- Timberlane TBLN
- TORREY HIGHLANDS
- UNIVERSITY CITY
- UNIVERSITY HEIGHTS
- Unknown 999
- Veranda VERA
- Vista del Sol VDS
- Vista Pacifica VP
- Walden WAL
- Webster Heights WBHT
- Woodcrest WT
- SAN DIEGO
- DOWNTOWN
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in San Diego as of Sep 10, 2026
1,662
Single Family Listed
59
Avg DOM
814
Avg $ / SqFt
$1,831,556
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the MISSION HILLS subdivision, 4250 Arguello Street San Diego CA is a Single Family for sale in San Diego, CA, 92103. It is listed for $3,495,000 and features 3 beds, 3 baths, and has approximately 2,500 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1917. The current price per square foot is $1,398. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in San Diego is $814. The average listing price for Single Family in San Diego is $1,831,556. To schedule a showing of MLS#260022158 at 4250 Arguello Street in San Diego, CA, contact your Pacific Sotheby’s International Realty agent at 6193633000.
Similar Listings Nearby
4250 Arguello Street
San Diego, CA