In California, homeowners face unique challenges when it comes to insuring their properties, particularly with fire insurance (which is typically one key component of most California homeowners insurance policies). Wildfires, climate change, regulatory complexities, and politics have made fire insurance more difficult and expensive to secure. Whether you already own a home or are considering purchasing one, understanding California’s homeowners and fire insurance market is critical for protecting your investment. At the end of this article, I will also share a guide from the California Association of Realtors on how to find (or keep) fire insurance.
California Homeowners Insurance in 2024 and Beyond – Why Has Fire Insurance Become So Difficult?
In recent years, securing homeowners insurance in California, especially fire insurance, has become increasingly challenging. Wildfires, fueled by climate change, have devastated vast areas of the state. This increased risk, combined with higher reinsurance costs and inflation, has led many major insurance companies, including State Farm and Allstate, to stop writing new homeowners policies in the state. These companies claim that current regulations make it difficult to adjust premiums to reflect the increased risk posed by wildfires.
California’s insurance market is heavily regulated by laws designed to protect consumers. Proposition 103, passed in 1988, limits the rate at which insurance companies can raise premiums. While this protects homeowners from sharp premium hikes, it also restricts insurers from using controversial, forward-looking risk models to assess potential wildfire risks. As a result, insurance companies can only set rates based on past events, which insurers argue doesn’t account for the increasing severity and frequency of wildfires in the state.
For many homeowners, especially those living in high-risk areas for fire danger, the lack of available coverage through traditional insurers has left them scrambling for options like the California FAIR Plan. This situation has created uncertainty for existing homeowners and potential buyers alike, as securing affordable fire insurance has become a critical factor in maintaining or purchasing property in throughout California.
The insurance situation in California has become dire enough that a contingency for investigating insurability is now one of the handful of contingencies included in the Residential Purchase Agreement. The Residential Purchase Agreement is what almost all offers for the purchase of homes in California are written on. The form is updated regularly by the California Association of Realtors.
Issues with insurability have caused some buyers to avoid homes in higher-risk areas altogether, and some transactions have failed when buyers discovered how problematic, expensive, and difficult insurance can be to obtain. What was once a mere formality in the home-buying process, securing insurance at a reasonable cost and with appropriate coverage has become a big deal.
Why is Homeowners Insurance / Fire Insurance Vital?
Homeowners insurance isn’t just about protecting your property from fire damage. It’s a comprehensive safety net that can protect you against multiple risks, including theft, vandalism, natural disasters, and personal liability. However, in a state like California, where wildfires can destroy entire communities, fire insurance plays a crucial role in ensuring that you can recover financially from such catastrophic events.
Without adequate California fire insurance, homeowners may find themselves in a precarious financial situation following a disaster. The cost of rebuilding or repairing a home after a fire can easily reach and exceed hundreds of thousands of dollars. If you’re underinsured or uninsured, the financial burden of recovery can fall entirely on you. For this reason, securing proper homeowners and fire insurance is not only a necessity but a cornerstone of responsible homeownership.
Fire insurance is also a requirement for homebuyers securing a mortgage. Lenders typically require that borrowers carry insurance to protect their investment. In high-risk fire zones, finding and maintaining insurance is as critical as securing a favorable mortgage rate. Before making an offer on a home, especially in wildfire-prone areas, prospective buyers should explore the cost and availability of fire insurance just as they would investigate loan options and obtain a preapproval.
Evaluating Insurability as a Home Buyer
One tricky aspect of doing investigating insurability before a specific property is identified is that fire risk and corresponding insurance costs/availability can vary dramatically, even in the same neighborhood. I have seen instances where a home is considered typical risk, but the home directly across the street is classified as a very high risk property. Sometimes that’s due to one home being on a canyon rim while another is not, but other times it can simply be the seemingly arbitrary risk lines calculated by government agencies.
Even though two homes might be on the same street, one might be easy to insure while the other might be very challenging to insure. For those reasons, it can be hard to really evaluate insurability until you identify a specific address. If you can do so quickly and without jeopardizing your offer, it is sometimes worth doing some investigating of insurability before you make an offer on a home.
Insurers Dropping and Non-Renewing Policies in California
California homeowners have faced an unsettling trend in recent years: insurers are increasingly non-renewing policies or exiting the state altogether. For consumers, this is an extremely unsettling and downright annoying experience. State Farm and Allstate’s decisions to stop writing new policies in California are among the most notable examples, but they are not alone. Other insurers have tightened their underwriting standards, especially in high-risk wildfire zones. This leaves many homeowners with fewer choices for coverage and, in some cases, with only one option – the California FAIR Plan.
Non-renewal means that when a policy expires, the insurer will not extend coverage. This can be particularly concerning for homeowners in areas classified as high-risk or very high-risk for wildfires, where the number of insurers willing to provide coverage has dwindled. However, California law mandates that insurers provide at least 75 days’ notice before canceling or non-renewing a policy. This gives homeowners some time to explore alternatives, but finding a suitable policy in such a short window can be challenging, particularly in fire-prone areas.
Numerous homeowners associations have been unceremoniously dropped by their longtime insurers, only to find new and comparable coverage nearly impossible to find. This has resulted in turmoil for both homeowners associations and the condo or townhome owners within that development. This turmoil has prompted massive special assessments and unanticipated costs for homeowners. It has also meant some associations are not as well insured as they once were since comparable coverage is not available or is cost-prohibitive.
In a partial response to this issue, the California Department of Insurance has implemented several consumer protection measures. These include temporary moratoriums on non-renewals following declared wildfire emergencies, giving affected homeowners time to secure alternative coverage. Still, the overall trend has been a reduction in available coverage, and many homeowners are turning to non-admitted insurers or the California FAIR Plan as a last resort. More on both of those shortly.
The Importance of Avoiding Being Underinsured
One common and significant risk that homeowners face, particularly in a state like California, is being underinsured. Underinsurance occurs when the coverage limits on your policy are insufficient to cover the full cost of rebuilding your home after a disaster. This often happens because homeowners fail to update their policies to reflect rising construction costs, the increased value of their property, or the replacement costs of personal belongings.
In the event of a fire or other catastrophic event, being underinsured can leave you with massive out-of-pocket expenses. For example, if your policy only covers $300,000 of damage, but the cost to rebuild your home is $500,000, you’re on the hook for the difference. Given the soaring costs of materials and labor, particularly after wildfires when demand for contractors skyrockets, it’s essential to ensure that your policy reflects current market conditions.
Homeowners should regularly review their insurance coverage, especially after making home improvements or significant changes to the property. Consulting with your insurance agent annually to adjust for inflation and rising construction costs can help you avoid a situation where your policy leaves you vulnerable.
Admitted vs Non-Admitted Insurers
Understanding the difference between admitted and non-admitted insurers is something many consumers are not aware of when navigating California’s challenging insurance market. An admitted insurer is a company that is licensed and regulated by the California Department of Insurance (CDI). These insurers are subject to the state’s strict regulations and are required to participate in the California Insurance Guarantee Association (CIGA), which provides financial protection to policyholders in the event that the insurer becomes insolvent.
Non-admitted insurers, on the other hand, are not licensed by the state but can still offer coverage. While they are not regulated as strictly as admitted insurers, non-admitted companies can often provide coverage in high-risk areas where admitted insurers may not. For homeowners in wildfire-prone regions, non-admitted insurers may be the only or one of the few available options.
However, working with a non-admitted insurer carries additional risks, as they are not part of CIGA and are not as closely regulated. Homeowners should be cautious and thoroughly research the financial stability of any non-admitted company they are considering. Resources like the AM Best Rating Service can help homeowners assess the financial health of these insurers.
The Value of Using a Good Insurance Agent or Broker
Given the complexity of the California insurance market, especially in high-risk areas, having a knowledgeable insurance agent or broker on your side is invaluable. A good agent can help you navigate the maze of available options, ensuring you get the best coverage for your specific needs at the most competitive price. They can also assist in understanding the differences between admitted and non-admitted insurers and whether a policy from the California FAIR Plan and what Difference in Conditions (DIC) policy is appropriate.
I have seen multiple clients successfully obtain California homeowners insurance after speaking with multiple insurance brokers. Each insurance agent or broker may have access to different programs. If one tells you it’s not possible, keep trying with other agents or brokers.
Independent agents, in particular, are a valuable resource because they work with multiple insurance companies and can offer a broader range of options. When selecting an agent or broker, look for someone with experience in your region and with knowledge of the specific risks you face as a homeowner in California. Recommendations from trusted sources, online reviews, and verification through the CDI are good starting points for finding the right professional.
The California FAIR Plan – A Plan of Last Resort
For many homeowners living in high-risk wildfire zones, the California FAIR Plan is the only option for securing fire insurance. The FAIR Plan is a state-mandated insurance pool designed to provide basic fire insurance coverage when traditional insurers refuse to underwrite policies. While it satisfies mortgage requirements, the coverage offered by the FAIR Plan is limited. It primarily covers fire, lightning, and smoke damage, and it does not include theft, liability, or water damage.
If you find yourself relying on the FAIR Plan, it’s essential to understand its limitations. Homeowners typically supplement their FAIR Plan coverage with a Difference in Conditions (DIC) policy, which can provide additional protection for risks not covered by the FAIR Plan, such as theft or liability. However, even with this supplemental coverage, the total cost may be higher than a standard homeowners policy and/or the coverage might be less comprehensive. Despite its limitations, the FAIR Plan can be a crucial lifeline for homeowners in high-risk areas who might otherwise be left without any insurance coverage.
Difference in Conditions Coverage (DIC)
A DIC policy is designed to bridge the gap between what the California FAIR Plan covers and what a traditional homeowners insurance policy would provide. While the FAIR Plan covers fire damage, it doesn’t extend to risks like water damage, theft, or personal liability. A DIC policy can be purchased separately to fill these gaps, offering more comprehensive coverage and peace of mind for homeowners relying on the FAIR Plan.
DIC policies are not always easy to find, and not all insurance agents may be familiar with them. Working with an experienced agent or broker can help you identify the best options for your needs. As the cost of fire insurance rises in California, more homeowners are turning to the FAIR plan coupled with DIC policies to ensure they are adequately protected against the major potential risks homeowners face.
Be Persistent – Patience Often Pays Off Even After Other Insurers Have Said No
It’s easy to feel discouraged after receiving multiple denials from insurance companies, but persistence often pays off in California’s complex insurance market. The landscape is continually evolving, and while one insurer may say no today, another could offer coverage tomorrow. By working with an experienced broker or agent, homeowners can explore all available options, including smaller or lesser-known insurers that may be willing to provide coverage in high-risk areas. Just because one agent, broker or insurance company says they can’t cover you does NOT necessarily mean no one will cover you.
Additionally, it’s worth revisiting the insurance market periodically. Even if you’ve settled on a California FAIR Plan policy, or an expensive non-admitted insurer, regularly checking for new private options can help you transition to more comprehensive and possibly less expensive coverage in the future. It’s also important to remain proactive in maintaining your home’s fire-resistant features and compliance with state regulations, as many insurers offer discounts or may reconsider providing coverage based on your property’s wildfire mitigation efforts.
What is Being Done to Improve Insurance Coverage in California?
Anyone having sought out insurance coverage in higher risk areas knows the state of homeowners insurance and fire coverage is an absolute mess. California’s insurance market is undergoing significant reforms aimed at stabilizing coverage options for homeowners, particularly those in wildfire-prone areas.
Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara has introduced a series of initiatives under the Sustainable Insurance Strategy to address the growing crisis. One of the most critical aspects of his plan is to modernize the rate-setting process for insurers by allowing them to incorporate forward-looking risk models. These models would enable insurance companies to better assess future wildfire risks rather than relying solely on historical data, which insurance companies feel is a major limitation under current law.
Additionally, Lara’s plan aims to ease the approval process for rate increases, making it faster and more transparent for insurers. This, he argues, would encourage more insurance companies to remain in California or re-enter high-risk areas, such as those near the wildland-urban interface. His strategy also includes efforts to stabilize the California FAIR Plan, ensuring that it remains a viable last-resort option by potentially increasing coverage limits and improving policyholder protections. The efficacy of any of these efforts remains to be seen.
Governor Gavin Newsom has supported these reforms, emphasizing the need to address climate change and the evolving nature of natural disasters in the state. While some consumer advocates worry that allowing rate increases might lead to higher premiums for homeowners, the Department of Insurance is trying to balance consumer protection with the financial realities facing insurers.
Lara’s proposal is still being fine-tuned, and it is unclear how effective the currently proposed reforms might be. The state is taking proactive steps to improve insurance availability while mitigating wildfire risks. For those seeking insurance now though, any regulatory or legislative improvements can’t come soon enough.
How a Real Estate Agent May Be Able to Assist You
As a real estate agent, I am well-versed in the challenges that California homeowners face when it comes to securing homeowners insurance, especially in the context of fire insurance. I frequently refer clients to reputable insurance brokers who can advise on available coverage options to help ensure that you find appropriate homeowners and fire insurance.
Additionally, I can assist buyers in providing resources and gathering essential documentation related to fire risks. Ultimately, while I’m not an insurance expert, my role as a real estate agent allows me to support my clients in navigating this complex landscape so they can secure the necessary protection for their homes.
Web Resources for California Homeowners Insurance / Fire Insurance
For homeowners and prospective buyers seeking more information on securing insurance coverage in California, the following resources provide valuable tools and guidance:
- California Department of Insurance (CDI): insurance.ca.gov – Offers guides, tips, and tools to help consumers understand homeowners and fire insurance options, including how to file complaints and find licensed agents.
- California FAIR Plan: cfpnet.com – The official site for the state’s last-resort insurance program, providing basic fire insurance for homes in high-risk areas.
- United Policyholders: uphelp.org – A nonprofit organization that offers resources to help homeowners understand their rights, avoid being underinsured and find the best coverage options.
- AM Best Rating Service: ambest.com – A resource for assessing the financial stability of insurance companies, particularly non-admitted insurers.
Guide on How to Find (or Keep) Fire Insurance
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal or financial advice. I am a licensed San Diego real estate agent, not an insurance expert. Please consult with an insurance professional for advice tailored to your specific situation.
Selling or Buying a Home in San Diego?
If you are considering buying or selling a home in San Diego and are looking for solid, conscientious advice from an experienced agent, please consider me a resource and reach out for a no-obligation consultation. I work with buyers and sellers at all price points and throughout most of the county.
Selling or Buying a Home Outside of San Diego?
Even if you are not in San Diego, I regularly refer people to outstanding Sotheby’s International Realty agents as a free courtesy, whether or not you are an existing client of mine. Our network encompasses 25,000+ sales associates in 1,000 offices throughout 70+ countries. Please let me know if I might be able to assist you with a real estate agent referral.
